A Completionist’s Take on Steam’s Achievement Overhaul
In 2008, Blizzard added achievements to World of Warcraft during the Wrath of the Lich King pre-patch. At the time, I had been playing since launch, four years at that point, and I was getting ready to call it quits. I had done everything the base game, and its expansion, The Burning Crusade, had to offer. Opening that achievement menu after updating the game changed my life, for better or for worse. I didn't end up quitting WoW and continued to play until the end of Legion in 2018 when I finally obtained every achievement in the game.
I've been a PC gamer since the 90s. I dabbled in console games here and there. It's unavoidable when you have five other siblings across two families. As you can see from my reviews, I rarely complete console games. The ones I have played generally have significant value to me from my childhood. Steam, however, is where my completionism lies, being the pinnacle of PC gaming since its inception.
Because I was so locked into WoW, I didn't make my Steam account until April 2011. Steam had added achievement support back in 2007, so coming to the platform was a no-brainer for me. Over the years, Valve made next to no changes to the achievement system, but I never noticed since it was already so great. Almost 20 years later, they changed that with this latest beta overhaul. I'm not going to go over every change because you can read them for yourself, but my friends have been asking me how I feel about the changes, so I'll give my thoughts.
Achievement Sets
There have been many games I left as beaten instead of completed because of multiplayer achievements. Max Payne 3 comes to mind. There are also games I haven't started because I don't have the DLC, nor the desire to buy it, despite wanting to play the game. A Hat in Time comes to mind. Achievement sets are supposed to fix that by letting people say they've completed a game without forcing them into often dead multiplayer games or making them buy multiple DLC. The only downside is that developers have to opt in. I don't have a lot of hope that older games will get the support they need. The video game industry is more likely to delist an old game than update it.
How I feel about this feature is still a bit messy. The DLC sets aren't going to matter much to me other than cool categorization. I'm always going to buy and play the DLC if a game has it, assuming it ties into the story and achievements. The multiplayer sets are where my real interest lies. We used to live in a world where multiplayer PvP was tacked onto story games in an attempt to retain your attention and farm microtransactions. While we've shifted away from this in favour of developers dropping the story part altogether and shipping only PvP games, those old games still exist. And that's where the problem lies; those games are the least likely to get updated. This is my primary doubt, but I'm choosing to be optimistic. We'll have to see what the future holds.
A quick note about seasonal sets. I feel the same way about them as I do about the DLC sets. They're a good way to categorize often obscure achievements while also providing the player with a visual timeframe of when they're available. Good stuff.
Changes to Steam Library & Profile
Achievement Menu
Aside from the achievement sets, Valve also changed the way achievements display across the platform. You can now pin achievements from your library or using the in-game overlay. I've already found this to be helpful for games that have a tracker with "do x 50 times". From those same menus, you can also compare achievements with multiple friends instead of one at a time in a separate window. Overall, these are beautiful visual changes that I'm happy to have, even if it took almost two decades to get.
Some changes were also made to your profile showcases that will take some time to get used to.
Achievement Showcase
First, the Achievement Showcase had its overall percentage removed. I wasn't concerned about this too much because I have a ton of games on Steam that I'm never going to play. However, they also removed it from individual achievements when you hover over them. It used to say something like, "globally, 0.1% of people have this achievement". I'm sadder about that, since my achievement showcase specifically details extremely hard achievements throughout the Halo franchise. I believe this is an oversight and that it'll be corrected before the beta ends, but people are going feral about it online.
Before and after:
Completionist Showcase
Second, the Completionist Showcase was changed. The banner across the bottom has been replaced with a trophy showing how many sets you've completed. They've also added how many rare achievements you have. To me, it just doesn't pop anymore. The blue banner made it stand out. With the black background, everything blends in and is harder to scan. Also, "rare achievements" is very subjective. Valve has never done a good job at tracking what a truly hard achievement is. They built their empire on allowing gamers to buy games easily and cheaply. When people are willing to spend money on games they'll never play, it makes many achievements overinflated in their rarity, simply because a decent percentage of people haven't played the game yet, and probably never will.
They also changed "Perfect Games" to "Games & Groups Completed". Again, I don't care about this too much, but it's another thing that people aren't happy about across the internet. Sure, "Games & Groups" doesn't sound as cool, but with this change, completing a set doesn't technically mean you've perfected the game.
Before and after:
Completed Games Page
Finally, they changed the completed games page. I don't have much to say about this one. They removed the ribbon from the artwork for completed games and added the trophy instead. Not many people use this page, but I used it on my website to show completed games. It'll look different now, but seeing how they handle sets on this page, it had to be done.
Overall, I'm happy about these changes. I'm hoping the beta goes well for Valve and they iron out the things they need. It's only been a couple days, but I'm eager to see how developers use this feature for both older games and new ones. Valve, if you're reading this, please add more completionist showcases!