Last.FM, LLMs, and the Continued Murder of the Internet

I don't need to be the millionth person to tell you this, but the internet you knew isn't coming back. Even the internet you hate, the one that came after the internet you knew, isn't coming back. For over a decade now, people have talked about the Dead Internet Theory, joked about the internet being nothing but bots, and complained that every website is trying to collect your data or sell you something.

Our heaven's no fun anymore.

Social media was the coffin, and LLMs are the nails keeping it shut.

Last.FM and the Unadulterated Internet

I made my first Last.FM account in 2007, when I was 13. I'm 33 now. For twenty years, it's been how I've bonded with my friends and made new ones. We compared stats in the school computer lab, went over to each other's houses to see what everyone had been listening to, and embedded our profiles on MySpace. It's been as big a part of my life as music itself.

A lot has happened to Last.FM since the end of the 2000s, and at the same time, nothing of interest has changed about its core functionality. They've had a few UI refreshes over the years, but that's about it. You listen to music, it tracks what you listen to, you get neat little graphs about your habits, and it recommends new music to you. That's all Last.FM has ever been to me, and all I've ever needed it to be. They've tried a ton of ventures to turn a profit since being bought by CBS (now Paramount) in 2007, but I simply never interacted with them.

The first change that really affected me came in 2024, when they announced the Pro subscription would be going from $30 to $50 a year. At the time, I was supporting Last.FM with a Pro subscription, but I wasn't using any of the features. To this day, none of the Pro features are worth paying for. I was essentially paying a company for no benefit other than supporting them, and I didn't really want to be giving Paramount money anyway. I couldn't justify the price hike, so I cancelled. As long as I could scrobble my music and see my stats, that's all I cared about.

Fast forward to 2026: I got an awesome email from Last.FM. They announced they'd been freed from Paramount and were now independent, followed shortly by a meet-the-team style post. The announcement made me quite hopeful. You don't often hear about a company letting go of an asset AND letting it stay independent. I was ready to start supporting them again. I just wanted to see any real change before getting my hopes up.

On 24 June 2026, they shared what they've been working on. Nothing crazy, but it had only been a month since independence, so I was happy to wait. After that, nothing changed on the site, and there were no more announcements until November 2026, when the bombshell dropped.

The Death of All Magic

On 18 November 2026, Last.FM announced that API access will be locked behind the Pro subscription, starting 1 December 2026. Thirteen days' notice. Moving forward, developers who make software that interfaces with Last.FM will need a Pro subscription, and users of that software will keep their free access. Awesome! What about self-hosted software, where every user brings their own API key? Well, now every one of those users is going to have to pay up as an individual!

The reason, of course, is money. And honestly, given the state of the internet, I don't entirely blame them. LLM scrapers have hammered everything from open-source projects like MusicBrainz to services like Last.FM. They claim that in recent months, their API has been getting an unsustainable number of requests from projects that appear to be mostly data scrapers that give nothing back to the community. While I'd argue that some data scraping does serve the community, through tools like fmbot, Topster, and SongStitch, I don't think John Vibecode is contributing anything by scraping data for some project with zero users.

Amid the chaos of their not-very-well-thought-out announcement, Last.FM jumped into the thread to make some clarifications.

A Last.FM staff reply in the announcement thread. A user asks: "Will this affect panoscrobbler and webscrobbler and similar?" Staff answers: "No, they will not be affected. Neither will fmbot, open scrobbler, universal scrobbler, foobar, Music Bee, scrubbler, neptunes, marvis, and others."

And others? You've got to be joking. It's been 36 hours since the announcement, and they still haven't clarified who "and others" includes, and are instead encouraging developers to reach out to them. Some developers will have to pay, and an unknown list of others won't. Do they need the money or not? The obvious answer is that they don't want to piss off the large number of people who use popular tools.

This is a good thing though, right? It's clear they're making this change because of the influx of AI scrapers and vibecoded projects with zero users. I do ultimately want Last.FM to survive.

All I've ever wanted was to scrobble my music and see my stats.

Well, if you haven't guessed by now, the tool I use isn't on that list.

Self-Hosting and the Hidden Costs of Control

I've been subscription-free for a long time. My partner and I run our own home server for music, movies, shows, images, and anything else you can think of that most people pay a subscription for. I don't believe in the cloud unless I am the cloud.

For music, I use Navidrome, a self-hosted music streaming server. It lets me keep all my music on my server, then stream it to whatever device I want. Naturally, Navidrome is in tune with the community of people who keep local music. It has integrations for MusicBrainz, ListenBrainz, and, importantly, Last.FM. Until now, setting up Last.FM was simple. You generate an API key on Last.FM, plug it into Navidrome, and you're scrobbling. That's all I use Last.FM for: scrobbling my music. Why would I pay $50 a year for Last.FM's most basic feature, and the only one I've ever used?

You might be thinking, "Wait, didn't Last.FM say popular software would be exempt?" Surely Navidrome counts, with almost 25,000 stars on GitHub and the title of most popular self-hosted music server? Wrong. In 2023, Last.FM emailed Navidrome's developer asking for the shared API key to be removed, which meant every user would need to generate their own.

A Discord conversation from 23 November 2023. A user tells Navidrome's developer, deluan, that Navidrome's built-in Last.FM API key is running into rate limits and asks if the docs should advise using your own. deluan replies: "Yes, I received an email from them asking me to remove the shared API key. Will do that today, and next release will not have the shared key anymore. I may even revoke the shared API key, and post in Discord/Reddit/X asking users to create their own key."

Navidrome did exactly what Last.FM asked. Every user generated their own key, just like Last.FM wanted. Now those are the exact users being told to pay up.

If you scroll through the replies to Last.FM's announcement, you'll find scathing criticism from self-hosters and everyone else left off the exemption list. Some of my favourites:

Ultimately, this is what companies do, and it's a struggle you have to live with if you're not an NPC. Companies will cut more and more niche users out of their software (even the ones who try to conform) until there are no niche users left. Use Spotify. Use Netflix. Give us money. Be told what to like. Be told what to consume. Be told what to do. Give us money.

If you're thinking, "Well, you don't pay for any subscriptions, so can't you afford just one?" consider this: I have to buy everything. You get your music for what basically amounts to free. I pay for every album from the artists I love. I want the artists to get the money, not Spotify. NEVER Spotify. If I were forced to spend another $50 on something, it would go toward more music from more artists. Not toward the privilege of scrobbling music to a barely functioning website.

I'm So Fucking Sick of AI

It's consumed my career. It's consumed the content I enjoy. It's consumed my tech-related peers. It's destroying the one thing that has brought me comfort my whole life.

Social media brought the beginning of the end of the internet. It's been a slow decline ever since Facebook introduced algorithmic feeds. Algorithmic content has destroyed the minds of the general population, and I see no way back at this point. I accepted this fate long ago. At the same time as cutting my subscriptions, I also cut ties with big tech platforms and all social media. I never thought anything could be more destructive to humanity than social media algorithms.

Fucking. LLMs.

The soulless husks left behind by social media naturally migrated to their sycophant of choice. LLMs have turned the least talented people in the world into unbelievable spam machines. Imagine The Fairly OddParents, except everyone gets their own wish-granting fairy, and it never leaves when they grow up. LLMs have ruined everything I once loved. They're scraping websites, overloading APIs, stealing anything and everything, cloning indie games and releasing them before the original developers can, and flooding niche FOSS projects run by a single person with junk pull requests. Nothing is safe, and just like with social media, it's only getting worse. This won't end until we're all forced off the internet. We're past the final nail. At this point, the entire coffin is made of nails, and Last.FM is the one that finally broke me enough to write a whole post about it.